WELCOME

INTRODUCTION

 

Welcome to my Chess Book Reviews blog. 

I hope you enjoy it and that it proves useful if you are deciding to buy chess books.

It has been said that books are the most loyal and trusted friends that you can ever have and in this world of iPads, kindles and other electronic formats I still want to be one of the people giving a 'shout-out' for hard copy chess books. In this technological age it has never been easier to access chess online, at the click of a mouse, and this has affected book consumption.  

Chess books are an important aspect of a chess players lives. They serve as an educational and developmental tool, as well as illustrating history and culture. Some people own one or several books, whereas others have large collections assembled over a lifetime. 

Truly then, I believe in the value of hard copy chess books. Unlike electronic books, they don't lose their charge, they can be read in the sunshine, they don't hurt your eyes from watching screens and even better - they can be autographed to add to their value as a treasured keepsake. 

I want to be clear about my objective for this blog site.

I am blogging simply as an amateur chess player. I am a club and county player, former County Chess Champion (Shropshire) and I have proudly represented and indeed been Captain of my country (UK) in the NATO Chess Championships, but I remain like many of us, just an ordinary player with a lifelong passion for the game.

My reviews are written for the people who are most likely to purchase chess books. That is to say beginners, intermediate and strong players up to county level, but I am sure that even stronger players might enjoy or in some way benefit from digesting my reviews. This is a not for profit blog but reviewing chess books is something that I enjoy.

Reviewing a chess book isn't as easy as one may think. It requires a certain skill-set and I am learning all the time. One has to be impartial and objective but also not be afraid to have a personal opinion and I will not shirk from criticizing if I feel it is warranted. There should be a standard process for the task of reviewing and it can take me a while - but that is because I will actually read the book. Too many people merely flick through and I have seen some truly woeful reviews consisting literally of a couple of lines. I want to try to get into the head of the author. I want to do the best I can to explain to the reader of this blog what each book is really about and the impact it had on me personally, so that they can make up their own mind about owning a copy. 

It is as subjective as art or music, but I hope my reviews are a good starting point for people. Naturally, individuals will have their own views and opinions about the same books. I am sanguine about that...but these views are mine and mine alone. Sometimes I may use humour to make a point (how dare I?) which is not everyone's style but there we are, that's life. It is not in the scope of this blog site to enter into debates. Feel free to make your own mind up. 

For the record I have several of my own favourite chess books from the past including 'The Sorcerer's Apprentice' by David Bronstein and Tom Fürstenberg. If you can still find it, then snap it up immediately. My most prized book is a signed copy of Anatoly Karpov's memoirs which he autographed when I played him in Chartres, France in a simul in 2019. 

As I say, you cannot autograph an iPad!

Without further ado then, let's put one foot forward and see where the journey takes us. Thanks for stopping by.

Carl

Carl Portman (Author: Chess Behind Bars and Chess Crusader)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The stories, games and intrigues of Capablanca & Alekhine

 

BOOK REVIEW by Carl Portman

The stories, games and intrigues of

CAPABLANCA & ALEKHINE  

by LUIS FERNÁNDEZ SILES

 

Luis Fernández Siles

Pages: 440

Independently Published   

2025 Hardcover

ISBN-13  979-8263686710

 

What is this book about?

It details the rivalry between José Raúl Capablanca and Alexander Alekhine. It also introduces the people and events around these giants of chess history and is a historical book of great relevance. It runs as follows:

·         Foreword by Manuel Azuaga

·         Introduction

·         16 Chapters

·         Epilogue

·         Index of games

·         Index of names

·         Bibliography

 

My thoughts and comments

I am going to begin at the end. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I have no hesitation in recommending it to everyone! I read it in three sittings to the exclusion of everything else. Firstly, how does this self-published tome look and feel? The (hardback) cover design is superb with the protagonists sitting at the chessboard oblivious of the background depicting the carnage and horror of war. They lived after all through WWII. Capablanca is studying the board whilst Alekhine looks away, seemingly lost in thought as well as (perhaps) the game. It is a brilliant idea, and credit to the designer Esther Alcedo Fuentes. The pages are of superior quality, with the font and diagrams being second to none.

 

I liked the look and feel of the book, and appreciate chess still being published in this format. It is liberally sprinkled with photographs that add value and meaning to the chapters. These include not only well-known images such as the sad depiction of Alekhine dead at the board in his hotel room in Estoril, Portugal (there’s a conspiracy piece about that in the chapter) but group photographs of other players in important competitions such as Pasadena 1932 and Wiesbaden 1929. I also love the group shot at Nottingham 1936. The reader will see and learn who Arthur John Mackenzie was, too.   

 

We are told that initially Capablanca and Alekhine got on very well, but after the latter had wrested the World Title from Capablanca in 1927 he refused to give him a rematch, making any number of excuses. I was reminded of Staunton and Morphy in the same vein. The author skillfully builds the story of their relationship over the years, culminating in the fact that at one point they refused even to be seen in the same room. I felt drawn into this, as if I were back in time witnessing these events. Reading about these two giants of chess, with all the background details was a delight for me, and I did learn some new things about both players.   

 

In one way I wanted to ‘take sides’ yet the fact is I am able to enjoy both players and their chess, regardless of their antics off the board. Capablanca did not like study and he was the more natural player whereas Alekhine was obsessed with study, analysis and improvement. Capa was supposed to be the endgame expert (and he was) showing depth and understanding in that aspect of the game whereas Alekhine was the one with flashes of brilliance and dashing attacks. Yet both were capable of either. José liked his women, and partying, Alexander had a penchant for alcohol. Both were chess gods in the world of 64 squares and both left legacies for us all, forever.  

 

There is so much more in this book including Alekhine’s joke, blindfold chess in prison, early examples of The London System instructive draws, Capa’s worst ever game, Lasker’s double bishop sac, Lilienthal’s famed queen sacrifice against Capablanca, Botvinnik’s legendary 30.Ba3!! against Capa, what Crapuloso means and much more. It’s a treasure trove of information with games and anecdotes to support the whole period. The Second World War greatly affected Alekhine in particular and chess in general. Was he an antisemite? After reading what the author provides, we must draw our own conclusions. For the Cuban his motivation seemed to (understandably) revolve around securing that rematch for the World Championship. It must have driven him crazy not being able so to do.

 

Game choice

There are 85 games. They are as instructive and interesting as one would expect from not only the two lead characters but also their opponents, including Lasker, Bogoljubow, Euwe, Nimzowitsch and Marshall to name a few. What really makes this book for me – and it is the most important point I can make – are the tremendous annotations from the author. Rarely have I read such an appealing style which players of all levels can understand. In a world where annotations can be very lazy, merely repeating what the engine says, Siles will go on to explain why he thinks the evaluations are so. He has a very clear way of explaining things and for me it was a true joy to follow, from beginning to end. He is one of the best I have read and that is a big compliment!

 

Here is a position from Alekhine-Capablanca, St Petersburg 1913

Capa’s queen is attacked. He now played the astonishing 33…Qc2!! Which Alekhine had never considered. There are many ‘wow’ factor positions like this, which is why we are so grateful for the games these superstars left us – who cares about computers?

 

Now, this is not a criticism but an observation based only on my preference. I would like to have had game numbers and the name of the Opening at the beginning of each game. Sometimes I flip through a book seeking only a specific opening. If these were included (and indexed) that would make life easier. But this does not detract in any way from the quality of the publication.

 

Conclusion

I said at the beginning of this review that I recommend this publication. I shall go a little further. Some of the books in my own collection are indispensable. Many are the classics such as My System, Lasker’s Manual of Chess. And My 60 Memorable Games. Well, The stories, games and intrigues of Capablanca & Alekhine can be added to that esteemed company. It is not only an instructive reference book, but an excellent work of chess history. The author says in his foreword that ‘this book takes a risk: most books about chess history don’t pay much attention to instructive commentary on the games, whilst most games collections don’t go deeply enough into historical context - I hope I have not been overly ambitious.’

 

Well the author can be justly proud of his book. That ’risk’ he took deserves to pay off handsomely. I only hope that he writes more – I am already having withdrawal symptoms. Christmas is fast approaching – and I will be recommending this to one and all.

 

Who is the author?

Luis Fernández Siles is a chess content creator, prevalent on YouTube, Twitch and Chessable with many interesting posts and articles. He has a deep love for chess, and lives in Granada, Spain.